a therapy session

What’s the Difference Between EMDR and Hypnosis

We live in a time of simple comparisons — designed to be shared in brief posts, tweets, etc. Life, of course, is far more nuanced than that. For example, when someone associates eye movement desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR) with hypnosis (hypnotherapy), it’s understandable at first glance. However, we can identify how these two treatment approaches differ upon closer examination.

Yes, they both involve specially trained practitioners inducing a mental state in which change is more possible. But, as always, there is more to this comparison. Not to mention, as with all healing modalities, a lot depends on the specifics of each situation.

EMDR and Hypnosis: Some Key Differences

a therapy sessionHypnosis can be very effective, but it is not a form of psychotherapy like EMDR. Hypnotherapy practitioners are not universally licensed or regulated, while EMDR is administered by specialists with advanced degrees. This is not meant to overstate credentialism’s role; instead, we must be acutely aware of who we trust with our mental health. Beyond that, here are three points of divergence between EMDR and hypnosis:

How Goals Are Addressed

No two people are the same. The same goes for mental health professionals. Thus, we are speaking generally when stating that EMDR is more typically used to address multiple goals. Hypnosis can be most effective with a single focus and shorter duration (see below). EMDR may involve fewer sessions than traditional talk therapy, but even so, it will almost always last longer than hypnotherapy protocols.

Dealing With Trauma

EMDR was initially designed for treating trauma. Its usage is far more widespread now, but EMDR remains a frontline approach for trauma survivors, including people with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) or complex post-traumatic stress disorder (C-PTSD). Hypnosis, on the other hand, can be most helpful for victims of trauma when used as a complementary tool.

Length of Treatment

As touched on above, EMDR has a predetermined protocol while hypnosis is more spontaneous. It could last a session or two, while EMDR usually lasts at least 8 to 12 sessions. This difference should not be viewed as an advantage or disadvantage, but it may be an issue. For some folks

Must We Judge One Option as “Better” Than The Other?

Of course, there is more to both options, but more to conversations like this. In a time when people seem particularly divided, we can practice making healthy comparisons right here and right now. You don’t have to demean one treatment in the name of preferring the other. In other words, there are many valid reasons why you might choose EMDR or hypnosis, which are not the same as criticisms.

Here are just a few of the crucial factors we must consider when choosing between EMDR and hypnosis or between any two mental health options:

  • If you have a personal preference, you may lean in that direction, but be sure to do your due diligence to learn as much as possible.
  • In instances when cost plays a deciding role, talk with the practitioners to see if any other options exist.
  • It’s common and easy to dismiss anything out of the ordinary (like hypnotherapy) as “woo-woo.” Even if you don’t try such a therapy, you can gain plenty from doing your own research.
  • Also, you or someone you know may have tried one of the choices you’re considering. This is an important consideration, of course. However, getting out of your comfort zone might be what you need!

Choosing between EMDR and hypnosis is an excellent way to find the treatment that’s ideal for you. It’s also an opportunity to hone your discernment and open your mind. Reach out to learn more about EMDR therapy.

Contact Us Schedule Online Now

0 replies

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *